Is It a Routing Issue or Switching Issue? Here’s How to Know — Fast!

by

We’ve all been there.
The network breaks, users complain, apps stop working… and your brain goes:

“Wait, is this a routing issue or a switching issue?”

It’s a common challenge. Routing and switching are two sides of the same coin — and when something breaks, the symptoms can look the same. But treating one like the other? That’s how you waste hours chasing the wrong thing.

Let’s solve that today — together.

This blog will walk you through how to identify whether your problem is Layer 2 (Switching) or Layer 3 (Routing) — using real-world logic, not just textbook theory.

First — What’s the Difference (Really)?

Switching (Layer 2) Routing (Layer 3)
Uses MAC addresses Uses IP addresses
Operates within a broadcast domain Works between different networks
Handles Ethernet frames Handles IP packets
Thinks in terms of ports & VLANs Thinks in terms of subnets & routes

So… when you can’t reach a device, how do you know which one is failing?

Let’s walk through the signs.

  1. Can You Ping a Device in the Same Subnet?

Here’s the first and fastest check.

Let’s say your IP is 192.168.1.10/24, and you’re trying to ping 192.168.1.20.

If the ping fails, then you’re both in the same subnet, so routing isn’t even involved.

That tells you:  This is a switching problem, not a routing one.

It could be:

      • Wrong VLAN assignment
      • Trunk/native VLAN mismatch
      • Spanning tree blocking the port
      • MAC address table issues

Quick commands to check:

show vlan brief          ← Check port VLAN

show mac address-table   ← See if MAC is learned

show interfaces status   ← Port up/down

show spanning-tree       ← Port blocked?

  1. Are the MAC Addresses Being Learned?

Let’s dig deeper into Layer 2.

When a switch sees a device send traffic, it records the MAC address on the incoming port. If that’s not happening, something’s broken on L2.

Check:

show mac address-table interface Fa0/1

If you don’t see the MAC address of the host — the switch isn’t learning it.

Could be:

      • Cable issue
      • NIC not sending traffic
      • Wrong VLAN
      • Port is administratively down

If the switch isn’t learning MACs, it’s definitely a switching issue.

  1. Can You Ping the Default Gateway?

This test is GOLD.

Let’s say:

      • Your PC is 192.168.1.10/24
      • The default gateway is 192.168.1.1

Try:

ping 192.168.1.1

If that fails, then your PC can’t even reach the first-hop router. That again points to a switching problem, or a bad default gateway config on the PC itself.

If it succeeds, but traffic still doesn’t go beyond — then we’re probably dealing with a routing issue.

  1. Is There a Routing Table Entry for the Destination?

Once the packet reaches the router, we move from Layer 2 to Layer 3.

Now the router asks:

“Do I know where to send this IP packet?”

To find out, check:

show ip route <destination IP>

If the router doesn’t have a matching route (or default route), it will drop the packet.

Now you know: This is a routing problem.

Also check:

      • Longest prefix match
      • Route learned via OSPF, EIGRP, BGP?
      • Administrative distance
      • Recursive static route issues
  1. Is NAT Configured (If Going to the Internet)?

Let’s say users can ping inside IPs, but nothing outside the network.

Layer 2 is fine
Routing is happening
But…

The problem? NAT is missing or misconfigured.

For internet-bound traffic, private IPs (like 192.168.x.x) must be translated to a public IP.

Check:

show ip nat translations

show run | include ip nat

No entries? No translations? Now you know where to look.

  1. Run Traceroute — It Tells the Story

Use traceroute to see where the packet dies.

      • If it dies on the first hop → Layer 2 problem
      • Dies on second or third hop → Routing
      • Gets to destination but still fails → Application or ACL

Example:

traceroute 8.8.8.8

If it doesn’t even leave the local subnet, don’t blame the router just yet. Go back to switching basics.

Real-Life Scenario Breakdown

Scenario 1:

A user on VLAN 10 can’t reach the internet.

Steps:

  • Can they ping their gateway?  → Switching issue
  • Port is in VLAN 20 instead of VLAN 10 → Fixed
  • Now they can ping gateway, but not outside
  • Checked NAT config → NAT missing → Fixed

Issue: Both Switching & Routing involved.

Scenario 2:

Two PCs in the same subnet can’t reach each other.

  • Checked VLAN → Mismatch
  • Switch not learning MAC → Port security enabled
  • Disabled port security → Works now

Issue: Switching

Scenario 3:

Ping works inside network, but DNS/web fails.

  • Traceroute reaches internet gateway
  • NAT translations missing
  • Added NAT overload → Everything works

Issue: Routing + NAT

Quick Cheat Sheet: Is It Routing or Switching?

Test Layer Interpretation
Ping to same subnet fails L2 Switching issue
Ping to gateway fails L2 Local VLAN/port/VLAN config
Ping to remote network fails L3 Routing issue
Ping to internet fails, but LAN OK L3/NAT NAT or default route issue
MAC not showing in table L2 Port/VLAN/cabling issue
Route missing in router L3 Routing table or protocol misconfig

Final Thoughts — Ask the Right Question First

Before you start typing router ospf 1 or changing trunks and VLANs, pause and ask:

“Where exactly is the packet getting stuck?”

Always start at Layer 1/2 and move up to Layer 3.
Most of the time, what looks like a routing problem is actually a switching mistake — and vice versa.

Knowing the difference saves you time, energy, and frustration.

Leave a Comment